Lgbtq Families The Ultimate Teen Guide
- Publication Date:
- January 1st, 2013
- Publisher:
- Scarecrow Press
- ISBN-13:
- 9780810885363
- ISBN-10:
- 0810885360
Why Lgbtq Families The Ultimate Teen Guide Has Been Challenged
Critics have targeted this guide less for any single passage than for its underlying premise, objecting to a teen reference book that treats same-sex and transgender parenting as an unremarkable family structure rather than a topic requiring parental discretion. See more ↓
Challenged or banned in 3 states across 3 school districts.
Overview
Eva Apelqvist's guide belongs to a shelf of reference books aimed squarely at teenagers rather than their parents or teachers. Its purpose is practical: to give young people who have two moms, two dads, a transgender parent, or another family configuration outside the traditional mold a vocabulary and a set of strategies for talking about their households with the wider world.
Structured like other entries in its series, the book likely blends first-person testimony from teens with straightforward explanations of terminology, legal history, and social dynamics. Rather than arguing a position, it seems designed to normalize what many readers are already living and to prepare them for questions, assumptions, or pushback they may encounter from classmates and relatives.
The tone aimed for in this kind of guide tends to be reassuring and matter-of-fact, treating LGBTQ-headed households as one variation among the many forms families take, and giving teens language to describe their own experience with confidence.
Context and Reception
Guides of this type emerged alongside a broader shift in young-adult nonfiction publishing, as libraries began stocking resources specifically for the children of LGBTQ parents rather than only materials marketed to LGBTQ youth themselves. That distinction matters: a child raised by two fathers is navigating a different set of questions than a teen exploring their own sexual orientation, and books like this one attempt to fill a gap that general-interest family literature left open.
Within the landscape of challenged titles, nonfiction guides occupy an unusual position. They are rarely accused of containing explicit scenes or provocative narrative content, since they are organized more like an encyclopedia entry or support manual than a story. Instead, objections to this kind of book tend to center on its premise — the idea that LGBTQ parenting is a legitimate family structure worth explaining to teenagers at all — rather than on any particular passage.
Why LGBTQ Families: The Ultimate Teen Guide Has Been Challenged
Gender identity and sexual orientation sit at the center of the objections raised against this title. Critics have argued that a reference book treating same-sex parenting and transgender identity as ordinary facts of family life amounts to an endorsement of those arrangements, rather than neutral information, and have questioned whether a school or public library collection should include a resource built entirely around that premise.
A related strand of criticism concerns age-appropriateness, with some challengers contending that discussions of sexual orientation and gender, even in a clinical or supportive register aimed at teenagers, belong to a conversation that parents rather than librarians or educators should initiate. Because the book is explicitly marketed to teens rather than to adult readers, it has drawn attention from those who believe such material requires parental gatekeeping before it reaches a school shelf.
In this catalog, the book has been reported as challenged or banned in 3 states and 3 districts, reflecting a pattern seen across many nonfiction titles addressing LGBTQ family life: the dispute is less about specific content within the pages than about whether the subject itself is suitable for inclusion in a teen collection.
Where to Buy
Affiliate links may generate a small commission at no extra cost to you, which helps support this site.
Banned in Schools
Banned or challenged in 3 states across 3 school districts.
Nation 1 district
Pennsylvania 1 district
- Lehighton Area School District Banned Pending Investigation
Texas 1 district
- Katy Independent School District Banned by Restriction