Big Nate Strikes Again
- Publication Date:
- January 1st, 2010
- ISBN-13:
- 9781484450499
- ISBN-10:
- 1484450493
- Pages:
- 216
Why Big Nate Strikes Again Has Been Challenged
Some parents and educators have pushed back on this installment for modeling a classroom culture of mockery, grudges, and corner-cutting that they feel goes unanswered by the narrative. See more ↓
Challenged or banned in 1 state across 1 school district.
Overview
"Big Nate Strikes Again" follows the further misadventures of Nate Wright, a sixth grader whose confidence in his own brilliance rarely lines up with his report card. The latest complication in his life comes in two parts: a school research assignment that pairs him with Gina, the insufferably perfect classmate he has sparred with since the first book, and a spot on his intramural team that Gina also happens to claim.
For Nate, these overlapping arenas of schoolwork and sports are supposed to be separate escapes — one a chore to survive, the other a source of pride. Having Gina present in both narrows his room to maneuver and forces him to interact with her on terms he didn't choose. The humor comes from watching a kid who prizes being right and being cool get boxed in by circumstances that reward neither.
As with the rest of the series, the plot is less about resolution than accumulation: comic-strip-style art, Nate's asides to the reader, and a procession of minor humiliations and small victories that make up an ordinary middle-school stretch. The Gina rivalry gives the book its throughline, but the appeal remains the same loose, episodic comedy that has carried the character since his debut.
A Rivalry as Structure
Lincoln Peirce built the "Big Nate" series around a simple engine: a kid convinced of his own exceptionalism, routinely undercut by a world that disagrees. Gina functions as the clearest counterweight to that self-image — not a bully or an authority figure, but a peer who succeeds at the very things Nate believes should be his. Pairing them for a shared assignment and a shared team is a tidy way to intensify that friction without introducing new conflict from outside the cast.
The book's comedy depends on readers recognizing the particular indignity of forced collaboration with someone you've decided to dislike. That scenario, familiar to anyone who has sat through a group project, is rendered through Nate's exaggerated, self-serving narration, which lets younger readers in on the joke even as they see through his unreliability. The series' durability owes much to this voice — petty, hopeful, and endlessly sure that redemption is one scheme away.
Why Big Nate Strikes Again Has Been Challenged
Much of the scrutiny directed at this entry, as with other "Big Nate" titles, centers on Nate's treatment of teachers and authority figures and his generally dismissive attitude toward school rules and expectations. Reviewers raising concerns point to the character's sarcasm, his schemes to avoid work or get even with classmates, and the way misbehavior is often played for laughs rather than corrected within the story, worrying that young readers might absorb the attitude rather than just the humor. The rivalry with Gina, built on mutual contempt and one-upmanship, has likewise drawn objections from those who would prefer peer conflict in children's books modeled on resolution rather than ongoing antagonism. According to the catalog's tracking, this title has been the subject of 1 challenge at the state level and 1 at the district level, reflecting a narrower pattern of concern than some of its series companions rather than a widespread campaign against the book.
Where to Buy
Affiliate links may generate a small commission at no extra cost to you, which helps support this site.
Also by Lincoln Peirce
Banned in Schools
Banned or challenged in 1 state across 1 school district.
Florida 1 district
- Union County School District Banned