Khaled Hosseini's The kite runner
by Harold Bloom
- Publication Date:
- January 1st, 2009
- Publisher:
- Bloom's Literary Criticism
- ISBN-13:
- 9781604131994
- ISBN-10:
- 1604131993
- Pages:
- 91
Why Khaled Hosseini's The kite runner Has Been Challenged
Concerns raised about this title stem less from its own analysis than from its function as a guide to source material involving assault and wartime violence, prompting questions about where such a companion belongs on the shelf. See more ↓
Challenged or banned in 1 state across 1 school district.
Overview
This volume is not Khaled Hosseini's novel itself but a critical study guide built around it, part of the long-running series of literary companions edited by Harold Bloom. Rather than telling its own story, the book collects essays, interpretive frameworks, and discussion material meant to help readers engage more deeply with Hosseini's account of Amir and Hassan, the fractured friendship at its center, and the historical upheavals in Afghanistan that shape their lives.
Bloom-edited guides of this kind typically combine plot summary and character analysis with excerpted or original criticism from multiple scholars, offering readers several lenses through which to view a text rather than a single fixed reading. The result functions less as a narrative in its own right and more as a reference tool: a way of unpacking themes, historical context, and structural choices for classroom use or independent study.
Because the companion is organized around Hosseini's novel, its content inevitably engages with the same difficult material the original book addresses, including violence, betrayal, and the legacy of trauma, filtered here through the additional layer of academic commentary and interpretation.
Context and Purpose
Harold Bloom's critical guide series has long occupied a particular niche in literary education, aiming to give students and general readers structured entry points into works considered significant additions to contemporary literature. Applying that format to The Kite Runner situates Hosseini's novel within a broader critical conversation about immigrant narratives, coming-of-age storytelling, and fiction that grapples directly with recent geopolitical history.
The companion's value lies largely in its function as a teaching aid: it exists to support readers who are also encountering the source novel, often in an academic setting, by supplying vocabulary for discussing theme and craft. Its reception is tied closely to that of the novel it analyzes, and its presence in libraries and classrooms generally reflects the continued curricular use of Hosseini's book rather than independent notoriety.
Why This Book Has Been Challenged
Because this title is a study companion rather than a standalone narrative, objections to it are best understood as objections to the appropriateness of its source material for certain shelving locations or age groups, rather than to the critical commentary itself. Reviewers and committees weighing its place in a library or classroom have generally raised concerns rooted in the underlying novel's frank treatment of sexual assault, violence, and abuse, material that the companion volume necessarily discusses and analyzes in the course of explaining the text.
Some objections center on whether guides built around mature source material should be shelved alongside the works they analyze, given that a companion volume can lead curious readers directly to the same difficult passages it summarizes and interprets. Others reflect broader unease about assigning texts, and their accompanying critical apparatus, that address war, cultural trauma, and interpersonal betrayal to younger students without additional guidance. According to the catalog's tracking, this title has drawn a challenge in 1 state and 1 school district, reflecting a narrow but real concern about its suitability rather than a widespread pattern of objection.
Where to Buy
Affiliate links may generate a small commission at no extra cost to you, which helps support this site.
Banned in Schools
Banned or challenged in 1 state across 1 school district.
Florida 1 district
- Escambia County Public Schools Banned pending investigation