Ancient Greece and Rome
by Tony Allan
- Publication Date:
- December 15th, 2011
- Publisher:
- The Rosen Publishing Group, Inc
- ISBN-13:
- 9781448859931
- ISBN-10:
- 144885993X
- Pages:
- 145
Why Ancient Greece and Rome Has Been Challenged
Objections to this volume have less to do with historical inaccuracy than with whether the frank violence and sexuality embedded in classical myth belong in material shelved for young readers. See more ↓
Challenged or banned in 1 state across 1 school district.
Overview
Tony Allan's "Ancient Greece and Rome" is a survey text aimed at readers curious about the belief systems underlying two of antiquity's most influential civilizations. Rather than tracing political or military history, the book turns its attention to cosmology, ritual, and the pantheon of deities that ordinary Greeks and Romans looked to for explanations of the natural world and human fate.
The book moves through creation stories, the hierarchy of gods on Olympus and in the Roman tradition, and the heroic figures whose exploits were told and retold across generations. It also considers how myth intersected with everyday practice, from household worship to civic festivals and oracular consultation.
As a reference-style work, it is structured to help students and general readers locate specific figures, stories, and concepts efficiently, with an emphasis on clarity over narrative flourish.
Myth as a Lens on the Ancient World
What the book is really doing is using mythology as a way of reconstructing worldview: how the Greeks and Romans organized the unknown, assigned meaning to natural phenomena, and used shared stories to reinforce social and religious order. This approach places it within a long tradition of classical education that treats myth not as fiction to be enjoyed in isolation, but as a window into how a civilization understood itself.
Its place in the broader genre of illustrated classical reference works means it is typically encountered in school and library settings as a supplement to history or literature curricula, valued for making a sprawling and often confusing body of legend navigable for younger readers.
Why Ancient Greece and Rome Has Been Challenged
A book praised in educational contexts for organizing a notoriously tangled body of legend into an accessible reference has, at least once, drawn scrutiny for the very material that makes classical mythology what it is. Greek and Roman myth is dense with content that some readers find inappropriate for younger audiences: stories involving sexual violence, incest, graphic violence, and the capricious cruelty of gods toward mortals. When these narratives appear in a reference book aimed partly at students, the tension between historical and literary fidelity and age-appropriateness becomes a point of contention.
Objections of this kind tend to center less on the book's factual accuracy and more on whether its intended young audience should encounter myths in their original, unsanitized form, given that the source material predates modern norms around depicting violence and sexuality in works for children. This title has been the subject of 1 challenge tracked in this catalog, spanning 1 state and 1 school district.
Where to Buy
Affiliate links may generate a small commission at no extra cost to you, which helps support this site.
Banned in Schools
Banned or challenged in 1 state across 1 school district.