Mooncakes
- Publication Date:
- January 1st, 2019
- Publisher:
- Lion Forge, LLC, The
- ISBN-13:
- 9781549303043
- ISBN-10:
- 154930304X
- Pages:
- 256
Why Mooncakes Has Been Challenged
Critics of the book have taken issue less with its witchcraft or monster-hunting plot than with its central romance between a nonbinary teenager and her werewolf love interest. See more ↓
Challenged or banned in 1 state across 1 school district.
Overview
Suzanne Walker's graphic novel follows Nova Huang, a teenage witch who spends her days shelving enchanted texts at the bookshop her grandmothers run in a sleepy New England town. When strange sightings of a white wolf draw her into the nearby woods, she finds herself face to face with Tam Lang, a childhood friend she hasn't seen in years — and a werewolf who has spent that time running from place to place rather than settling anywhere for long.
Tam is being hunted by forces that want to harness wolf magic for their own ends, and turning to Nova is less a choice than a last resort. As the two reconnect, old affection resurfaces alongside new danger, and Nova is pulled deeper into spellcraft she's only begun to understand. Family history, inherited magic, and the pull between two people who once knew each other well all tangle together as the threat closes in.
Illustrated in a style that favors mood and texture over spectacle, the story moves at the pace of a quiet small-town mystery even as it builds toward confrontation with the occult forces pursuing Tam.
A Story About Belonging, Told Through Witchcraft
Mooncakes uses its supernatural premise to ask a fairly grounded question: what does it take to feel at home somewhere, in a place or in a body? Tam's years of wandering are framed less as adventure than as exile, and the book treats the search for a fixed point — a person, a town, a sense of self — as its real engine, with the magic serving as a lens on identity rather than an end in itself. Nova's position within a household of practicing witches gives the story a matter-of-fact relationship to magic, where spellwork is treated as inherited craft and family obligation as much as mystery.
The book arrived as part of a wave of graphic novels aimed at teen and young-adult readers that paired genre storytelling — werewolves, demons, rival covens — with earnest attention to character interiority, including a nonbinary main character whose identity is presented without being treated as the plot's central problem. Within Walker's body of work and the broader comics landscape it sits alongside, Mooncakes is often discussed as an example of how speculative fiction can carry quieter, character-driven concerns about family, chosen community, and reconciling who you were as a child with who you're becoming.
Why Mooncakes Has Been Challenged
A parent raised the book with their district's review committee on the grounds that its romance between two teenage characters, one of them a nonbinary werewolf, was inappropriate content for a school library shelf aimed at adolescent readers. The complaint centered less on the book's supernatural plot than on its handling of a same-sex relationship and gender identity, arguing that the subject matter belonged in a different section of the library or shouldn't be available to students at all. That framing has made Mooncakes part of a broader pattern of challenges directed at young-adult titles featuring LGBTQ+ characters, where objections are typically aimed at the presence of queer identity and romance rather than at violence, language, or other conventional content concerns. In the catalog tracked here, the book has been formally challenged in one state and one school district.
Where to Buy
Affiliate links may generate a small commission at no extra cost to you, which helps support this site.
Banned in Schools
Banned or challenged in 1 state across 1 school district.