Frankissstein
- Publication Date:
- October 1st, 2019
- Publisher:
- Grove Press
- ISBN-13:
- 9780802129505
- ISBN-10:
- 0802129501
- Pages:
- 258
Why Frankissstein Has Been Challenged
The book has drawn objection mainly for its frank treatment of a transgender character's intimate relationships and body. See more ↓
Challenged or banned in 1 state across 1 school district.
Overview
Jeanette Winterson's novel moves between two timelines joined by a single question: what does it mean to build a body, or a self, from scratch? In 1816, a teenage Mary Shelley sits beside Lake Geneva and begins imagining a creature stitched together from borrowed parts. In present-day Britain, a transgender doctor named Ry becomes entangled with Victor Stein, a charismatic AI researcher whose underground laboratory experiments push past the edges of what medicine and ethics currently allow.
Around this central pairing, Winterson builds out a wider cast testing the same idea from different angles. Ron Lord, newly divorced and back in his mother's house, is betting his future on a line of increasingly lifelike sex robots. In Arizona, a cryogenics facility holds the dead who are legally gone but chemically suspended, hoping science will eventually call them back.
The novel threads these stories together rather than telling them in sequence, letting echoes accumulate between Shelley's original monster and the manufactured, modified, and frozen bodies of the modern plot.
Shelley's Monster, Reconsidered
Winterson has long used fiction to interrogate inherited categories, and this novel places her squarely in conversation with the writer who may have started that conversation for English literature. By returning to the origins of Frankenstein's monster, she asks what has and hasn't changed in two centuries of imagining artificial life: the same anxieties about hubris and creation now attach themselves to machine learning, gender-affirming medicine, and the commercial pursuit of eternal life.
The book sits comfortably alongside Winterson's earlier work in its refusal to let identity, gender, or desire stay fixed. Ry's relationship with Victor becomes the emotional center of a novel that is otherwise preoccupied with ideas, grounding abstract questions about consciousness and embodiment in an actual, complicated romance. Reviewers noted the book's willingness to be funny and theoretical in the same breath, and its Booker Prize longlisting reflected recognition of that balancing act within contemporary literary fiction.
Why Frankissstein Has Been Challenged
Depictions of gender identity and sexuality sit at the center of the objections this novel has attracted. Ry's transgender identity is portrayed without euphemism, including candid passages about physical transition and intimacy with Victor, and some readers and reviewing bodies have objected to that content as inappropriate, particularly in school library settings. The novel's broader sexual frankness, including its treatment of Ron Lord's sex-doll business, has compounded those concerns for challengers focused on sexual content generally.
Underlying many objections is discomfort with the book's unflinching stance that gender and sexuality are fluid rather than fixed categories, a position woven into both its contemporary plot and its narrative voice. Records in this catalog show the novel has been formally challenged in 1 state and 1 school district, reflecting a response concentrated in a small number of jurisdictions rather than a widespread pattern.
Where to Buy
Affiliate links may generate a small commission at no extra cost to you, which helps support this site.
Banned in Schools
Banned or challenged in 1 state across 1 school district.